Need help breaking free from addiction?
Call 24/7 for treatment options. Who Answers?

It Seems Like I Have To Choose Between My Husband And My Son!


i am just lost and don’t know what to do .. i have 3 sons. 17,11,6 i am married. my husband now is the father of the 6 yr old . and yes he does treat him different then the other two . well my 17 yr old does not get along with my husband at all . me and my husband have been together for ten yrs now . this morning was another all out war between them which resulted to physical violence. i was at work . my son is calling screaming at me on the phone saying how he is being a jerk cause he cant use the truck which we gave to him . to go to school. then my husband gets on the phone screaming at me saying i need to choose between him and my son.. well I’m sorry but I’m gonna choose my son he is my blood i gave birth to him . my husband always says that him or me.. what am i supposed to do. it would break my 6yr olds heart if i let his daddy go. and financially i can not make it . my husband does drink a lot i’ve tried to tell him stop or i will leave. i left my first husband cause of it then i only had one child and i did make it on my own but now i have 3 . i’m so stressed…please any advice..thank you.

This Disclaimer applies to the Answer Below
  • ‘Anne’ is the pseudonym for the individual who writes this relationship advice column.
  • ‘Anne’ bases her responses on her personal experiences and not on professional training or study. She does not represent herself to be a psychologist, therapist, counselor or professional helper of any sort. Her responses are offered from the perspective of a friend or mentor only.
  • Anne intends her responses to provide general information to the readership of this website; answers should not be understood to be specific advice intended for any particular individual(s).
  • Questions submitted to this column are not guaranteed to receive responses.
  • No correspondence takes place.
  • No ongoing relationship of any sort (including but not limited to any form of professional relationship) is implied or offered by ‘Anne’ to people submitting questions.
  • ‘Anne’, Mental Help Net and CenterSite, LLC make no warranties, express or implied, about the information presented in this column. ‘Anne’ and Mental Help Net disclaim any and all merchantability or warranty of fitness for a particular purpose or liability in connection with the use or misuse of this service.
  • Always consult with your psychotherapist, physician, or psychiatrist first before changing any aspect of your treatment regimen. Do not stop your medication or change the dose of your medication without first consulting with your physician.

Given the serious issues that you are confronting, including marital problems, domestic violence and substance abuse, and the difficulty of really understanding your situation at the level of detail that is required to know how to best help you problem solve, I’m going to recommend right up front that you seek counseling immediately. You need support and guidance that no one who is unfamiliar with your particular circumstance can provide.

From a distance, we can make some observations and suggestions, however. The first thing that leaps out here is that yours is a family with boundary issues . You are more allied with your son than with your husband (and the father of your other son), and that is not the way to keep a marriage strong. I’m not saying that your marriage is worth preserving, because I don’t know the circumstances really, but on the assumption that it is, your taking the side of your son, particularly with regard to what sounds like a rather petty conflict (there are other ways to get to school than driving there yourself in a truck!) is just going to alienate your husband. It would alienate any partner to have their authority undermined in such a manner.

It’s not really important who started it (your son or your husband), or who is right (everyone is going to feel justified in this sort of circumstance). What is important is that you need to keep the level of tension and hostility down in the house. In order to do this, you need to set some rules up that will make it clear how this sort of problem will be solved. Provided that your husband is not a true danger to you or your children, my recommendation is that you and your husband get together and figure out what these rules should be (what you both can live with) with regard to driving to school, and then present them to your son as a unified couple. Your son then needs to play by those rules, even if he doesn’t like them (which is likely). If he doesn’t like them, in a year or so he can move out of your house and make his own rules (if he can support himself). Until then, he has to put up or shut up. This is not being cruel to your son; it is just setting reasonable limits on him; something many parents strive to do. He is testing the limits now to see what he can get away with (which is apparently everything he wants), and your unfortunate husband, who is already handicapped by not being the boy’s real father, is perhaps an unfortunate casualty of this adolescent breaking away process. By setting rules with your husband that you both can live with, and by presenting those rules to your son as a unified couple, you reinforce your husband’s authority to enforce the rules you’ve both agreed to and make his life as a step-parent easier. By enforcing the rules even when your son goes around your husband to see if he can sweet talk you into getting what he wants, you show your son that he has to live by the rules. When the limit is set and enforced by both you and your husband, there will likely be more peace in the house. In the process, you bring yourself closer to your husband and maybe that relationship gets a little better.

All by itself, your husbands drinking sounds like it could be enough to undermine your marriage. It is very difficult if not impossible to get someone else to limit their drinking or stop drinking entirely. If it is possible at all to do this, what would work would be a loving approach rather than an attacking one. If you nag him to stop drinking or yell at him to stop drinking, he will likely get defensive. If the quality of your relationship improves enough so that you can have a heart to heart and express your concern about his drinking and how it makes things so difficult for you, you might have a (slim) chance. It is perhaps worth trying, anyway.

Working to express affection rather than disdain for your husband is part of working on saving your marriage. However, it isn’t clear what you want, maybe even to you. You give two reasons why you need to stay with him (e.g., that you can’t afford to be on your own, and that it would hurt your youngest child to be apart from his father), but neither of them has anything to do with your feelings for him. Maybe those feelings are gone and died, or maybe they are just temporarily suppressed given the tension you’re experiencing. Even if you don’t love this man, it may be worthwhile to act as though you do for a time and work on drawing a healthy relationship boundary around yourselves anyway. You may find that your interest in the man becomes renewed, especially if he responds to your allying yourself with him by becoming an easier person to be with. Even if that particular positive outcome doesn’t occur, you might find that there is more peace in your house anyway, which would be a benefit. You can always divorce him later.

More "Ask Anne" View Columnists

  • Morgan

    I have read your problem and also read the response. Basicially what your son is feeling is pretty normal, most marriages that end in divorce where children are involved "mostly in males" they feel that they may have caused a split in your first marriage in which I persume is his real father. I have a son who was 16 years of age when I married a man that was 5 years younger then me which made it impossible for my husband to be his father figure. everytime me and my husband gets into an argument my son buts in he feels like its his place to protect me for some reason, my hubby does not drink however but my son and husband has had physical altercations to and its hard but I have been married 3 times and my husband did make a difference between my kids too he treated his better and the fact is your husband holds a grudge against your son because he belongs to your first husband hes jealous and he does and says things to your son behind your back most likely here is what I did I got a voice activated tape recorder and left it in the room they were most likely to be talking ot arguing and I heard for myself what actually happened and my husband also gave my son a truck too and then didnt want him to drive it if my son said or did something he didnt like. to be honest its hard for your son being treated differently and you answered your own question when you said you made it once before but try the tape recorded sometimes hearing proves a little more truth to the story you are being told and I think that you may find out the truth Good Luck if you would like to talk let me know leave your email address and I will write to you

  • Anonymous-1

    OMG I am going through the exact same thing. The only problem is that mine has now come to a head! My husband evicted my son and my husband has left the marital home. I feel the right thing to do would be to divorce my hubbie (as in my head I feel as if he has made me choose).. Deep down I know he has not made me choose but has in fact tried to make me see what was happening over the years...

    I dont know what to do, I am going through sheer hell at the moment..!! Can someone please help me!

  • Anonymous-2

    I have been married 13 years, I had a son and daughter from my previous marriage, and we have a son aged 12 together. the relationship with my other son, 19 has always been strained, as my husband would never tolerate him talking back or having any opinion really. At 16 my ex husband talked him into going to stay with him, that put a lot of strain on me, but after a year he asked to come back. Since then my husband has treated him like sh*t. The smallest thing would be an issue. He dropped out of varsity and got a job, not earning a lot of money, but hoping to work himself up in the company. A week ago my husband shouted at him about something, an absolute misundertsanding, and when my son told him that he did not do anything wrong, he lost it. Chased him out and said he never wanted to see him again. I told him that this was really a misunderstanding. he said he is arrogant and i should choose whether it's him or me. W havent spoken since !! What do I do! My son has nowhere to go. He took his car away as well.

  • molly

    I feel so bad for all of you. My situation is a little different. My children are all grown, and don't live at home.

    Well my husband lost his job and went to jail for watching teen porn. And i left but after a couple of years of being on my own. I realized i still love him.

    I know what he did was so wrong, he knows that too. He did his time went for therapy. And has since tried to become a good person.

    He also knows being with me would be difficault he won't be able attend any or family gatherings. The only people still talking him are his parents and sister. Who by the way somehow blame me for what he did.

    His therapist has said they are part of the problem as they have never made him accountable. Plus he has PTSD after 20 years in the Army.

    Anyway my children are making me choose. And oh god i understand them. If you had ask me a couple of years ago. I would have been leading the charge. With the biggest stick.

    But at the same time, this man is so broken. And it breaks my heart to see him this way. He has always treated me and my family with respect. Something there own father couldn't do. My childrens father was also an Alcaholic and was a poor excuse for a husband.

    And i know most people will say run. But at 62 its just not that easy. I feel like i am facing the rest of my life alone. While my children all have lives. And sometimes even act like im a burden. Don't get me wrong they love me but getting invited over once in a while. Or baby sitting dose not take away my loneliness and missing my husband. The life i had.



Call the Helpline Toll-FREE

To Get Treatment Options Now.

1-888-993-3112 Who Answers? 100% Confidential

Get Help For You or a Loved One Here...

Click Here for More Info.


Call The Toll-FREE Helpline 24/7 To Get Treatment Options Now.

100% Confidential
Get Treatment Options From Your Phone... Tap to Expand